Are half-siblings considered full-siblings if there is no will?

Does a half-blood sister inherit the same as a whole-blood sister? Let’s start with the idea that relatives of the Half-Blood inherit the same as they would if they were relatives of the whole blood. Is Harry Potter coming to mind when you think of “relatives of the half-blood?” Thanks to J.K. Rowling, the concept of the “half-blood” now has a colloquial meaning as well as a legal meaning, although there is much less suspense or cliff-hanging-ness about the legal concept of  half-bloods as compared to the magical concept of a half-blood. (And usually less discrimination as well. Usually.)

Around the legal community, relatives of the half-blood refers to half-brothers and half-sisters. This typically means that you share one parent, but not both. So you might have the same mother or same father, but not both the same mother and same father.  What does that mean for your inheritance from your parents?

Let’s Talk about the Acerra Family

Louis M. Acerra was only 30 years old when he died from serious injuries he received in a house fire caused by a defective dishwasher. In 2009, he suffered from third-degree burns to most of his body. He survived for two years before passing away in 2012. At the time of his death, Mr. Acerra was a single man. He had never married and he didn’t have any children. While he was still alive, a lawsuit was filed on his behalf against the manufacturer of the dishwasher for negligence and for Louis’s injuries. While the suit was pending, Louis passed away. His estate was eventually awarded $4,706,250 in a settlement.

Since Louis had not created a Will, the money that was awarded to his estate would be divided under the New Jersey Intestacy Statutes. These statutes determine who receives what and in what percentage. It tries to divide things in an a way that most people typically do, so there’s an amount left to a surviving spouse or domestic partner, then to children, then to parents, then to grandparents, then to aunts and uncles, then to step-children.

In Louis’s situation, he was not married so there was no spouse or domestic partner. He had not had children. His mother had passed away before him. His father was unknown and so where his whereabouts. And both of his grandparents had passed away. His mother had two living sisters who had the same biological parents as she did. But, his mother also had five half-sisters.

Look … a color coded chart to make it easier!

The intestate laws are pretty straight-forward for his mother’s full sisters. They would evenly split the $4.7 million. Talk about a big pay day!

However, under New Jersey law, relatives of the half-blood inherit as if they were relatives of the whole blood. In this case, there was a question of whether “relatives” refers to all relatives, or only siblings. There was also a question of whether the descendents of one grandparent, but not both grandparents, are meant to be included as intestate heirs.

Their argument makes sense, right? When you think of a “half-blood relative,” most people think of half-siblings, not half aunts and uncles. In fact, the previous version of the statute only included half-siblings, and did not include half-cousins. (36 N.J.L. 418 (E. & A. 1872)), but that law was changed. With the statute changing, the implication and application of the law also changes. Besides all the legal jargon, it seems a lot more appealing to the two aunts to split a $4.7 million inheritanceThis amount was also divided by court costs and attorneys fees, so it was a number less than $4.7 million, but the court opinion doesn’t make clear what that amount was. between two people instead of among seven people, five of whom are half-siblings.

The court decided that the word “relatives” include all relatives, including those half-aunts of Louis who wanted a portion of the settlement from his injury. It might sound like they were chasing his money, but it was their right under the law to receive a portion of the settlement since Louis had passed away.  

There are two lessons to be learned from Louis Acerra’s case.

The first is that yes, half-relatives are considered whole-relatives, no matter how remote the “half-ness” so long as we are at that level of the intestate succession. This could potentially include half-cousins.

The second lesson, make your Will. It doesn’t matter how young or young at heart you are. Sure, you don’t want to think about dying. That’s a tough thing to think about when you’re in your 20s, but Louis was injured at 28, hadn’t made a Will, and died at 30. He was a young person who suffered a horrific accident. He had no control over what happened to the settlement proceeds from his injury and it resulted in a massive, complicated lawsuit that included around sixteen people, at least five attorneys, and at least three judges to determine how Louis’s estate should be divided.

In the Matter of the Estate of Louis Acerra is an unpublished opinion, which means that it is not presidential or binding on any person or court except the parties involved.


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on linkedin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

plan for tomorrow so you can enjoy today

When you create you Last Will and Testament (or Living Trust) using the Giving Forward Program, you get organization, customization, and an easy to follow program that walks you through the four-step process so you are in control and get to create your own unique and customized Giving Forward plan.

Apply Now

Self-Service and DIY Legal Templates

On Key

Related Posts

Create Your Quarantine Routine

What do you think of when you hear the word “routine?” Does it make you think of monotony and boredom? Or does it make you feel serene, calm, and have peace of mind?

Up until a few weeks ago, every day was the same. Wake up, go to school/work, eat, school/work, come home, dinner, bed. That’s all changed and routines have flown out the window!

Just think about how powerful you could be if you tweaked your routine to allow more time for you to build your legacy in the world.

What happens to Alice if I die? A Look at Gertrude Stein’s Last Will and Testament

Gertrude Stein died in 1946, just three days after writing her Will. No one imagined that 21 years later, her life partner, Alice Toklas, would die impoverished, half-blind, and half-deaf. During the later years of her life, Alice relied upon the goodwill and solicitations of friends to keep a roof over her head. What went wrong with Alice’s Will that resulted in the of her life dying in poverty?

Is it worth creating an Advanced Health Care Directive if a hospital issues a blanket “do-not-resuscitate” order?

In March of 2020, at the height of the COVID-19 Pandemic in NJ, it was been reported in several newspapers that there are whispers and some outright discussions about hospitals and states issuing blanket “do not resuscitate” orders for patients having coronavirus. Can hospital override the medical wishes outlined in your living will? If so, how? If not, how can you protect yourself?

How to talk to your parents about aging and dealing with their “stuff”

One of the biggest questions we get around the holiday season is … “How do I talk to my parents about their stuff?”

And this question is then awkwardly followed by, “Look, I don’t really want or expect anything from my parents, but I just don’t know what to do if they get sick or … fall down when I’m not home and …. you know…” and the person then trails off.

It’s hard to talk to your parents about them getting older and becoming more frail. Here are a few ways to start that discussion.